Hmm...that's a tough question, and one I've never gotten before. (And
those are hard to come by, lemme tell you.)
If I'd gone right into the series in 1986, what would've been different in
the writing and the show in general...hmmm.....
Given my notes of the time, I think it probably would've been more from
Sinclair's point of view. The characters would've likely been more
defined in terms of their relationship with Sinclair, as opposed to seeing
their lives out on their own, without that defining *context*. That's
probably the single biggest creative difference. I don't know if I
could've given it the depth of characterization or sub-plots that I feel I
can do now. Certainly, the time spent on Murder, She Wrote taught me a
*lot* about setting up clues, foreshadowing, construction, and playing
fair with an audience, experience I didn't have in 1986.
On the other side, you've got the reality that CGI wasn't available then,
and it'd all have to be done with models. It would've been *very*
difficult to do all we've done now with CGI, using models; I think you'd
have to cut way back on the scale of the thing. It's very doubtful we
could've done the Narn homeworld bombing from "Twilight," or the rescue in
"Fall." I'd've had to come up with some other way to do that.
Basically, I think the show would've still presented an arc, still
would've been ambitious for its time, but I don't think it would've been
*as good* as it is now. In a way, though the long wait was frustrating,
it put us in the right place at the right time to do this show the way it
needs to be done, both creatively and physically, from a production
standpoint.
On the other hand, one can probably make a good argument that if the show
were done in the year 1999 instead of 1996, with even 3 years more
advancement in CGI and EFX, and 3 more years of writing experience, it
might be even better then than now. Who knows? All I know for sure is
that the show being done now, is the show I want to do, the way I want to
do it, and I'm very comfortable with that.
jms